Why Correct Reconciliation of GSTR 3B, GSTR 9 & GSTR 9C is Important?

Why Correct Reconciliation of GSTR 3B, GSTR 9 & GSTR 9C is Important?

Goods and Services Tax was implemented to simplify the indirect tax structure. However, as businesses battle with the complexities of compliance, one issue that has consistently arisen is the mismatch between GSTR-9, GSTR-9C, and GSTR-3B. These three forms play a crucial role in the GST framework, and discrepancies can lead to compliance challenges and potential legal implications. The following article discusses how businesses are affected by such a mismatch.

What is GSTR 3B?

GSTR-3B is a monthly return filed by registered taxpayers to report their summary of outward and inward supplies, along with the taxes payable and paid for a given month. It is a provisional return and a crucial document for tax authorities to assess taxpayers’ tax liability.

What is GSTR 9?

GSTR-9 is the annual return that taxpayers are required to file. It consolidates the monthly GSTR-3B returns information for the entire financial year. It summarizes the taxpayer’s activities, including input tax credit (ITC) availed, output tax liability, and taxes paid.

What is GSTR 9C?

GSTR-9C is a reconciliation statement and certification of reconciliation between GSTR-9 and the audited financial statements of a taxpayer. It is mandatory for taxpayers whose annual turnover exceeds Rs. 2 crores and must be certified by a chartered accountant (CA) a cost accountant.

Common Errors While Filing GSTR 3B:

  • Incorrect Reporting of Turnover: Ensure that the turnover is reported accurately, including both taxable and exempt supplies. Errors in turnover can lead to incorrect tax liability calculations.
  • Mismatch in Input Tax Credit (ITC): Reconcile your purchases and ITC claimed. Common errors include claiming ITC on ineligible items or missing out on eligible ITC.
  • Incorrect Tax Rate and Calculation: Tax rate selection or calculation errors can result in underpayment or overpayment of taxes.
  • Late Filing: Filing GSTR 3B after the due date attracts late fees and interest. Ensure timely filing to avoid penalties.
  • Mismatch in Data: Consistency in data across various sections of the return is crucial. Discrepancies can trigger notices from tax authorities.

Common Errors While Filing GSTR 9:

  • Incomplete Data: Ensure all relevant data is included in GSTR 9, including details of outward and inward supplies, ITC, and amendments.
  • Mismatch with GSTR 3B: GSTR 9 should reconcile with the data reported in GSTR 3B. Any discrepancies should be rectified before filing.
  • Omission of Amendments: If you made any amendments during the financial year, ensure they are reflected in GSTR 9.
  • Mismatch with Books of Accounts: Ensure that the data in GSTR 9 matches your books of accounts. Any discrepancies can lead to scrutiny.
  • Non-Compliance with GST Rules: Failure to comply with GST rules and regulations, such as reverse charge mechanisms, can result in errors.

Common Errors in GSTR 9C (GST Audit Report):

  • Reconciliation Errors: GSTR 9C involves reconciling data between the financial statements and GST returns. Errors in this reconciliation can be a major issue.
  • Inaccurate Certification: The auditor must accurately certify the reconciliation statement. Any inaccuracies can lead to legal consequences.
  • Non-Disclosure of Additional Liabilities: Any additional tax liabilities identified during the audit should be disclosed in GSTR 9C.
  • Missing Supporting Documents: Ensure all relevant documents are provided to the auditor and attached to GSTR 9C.
  • Incomplete Information: Please complete the information in GSTR 9C to avoid errors and discrepancies in the audit report.

Consequences of GSTR 3B & GSTR 9 mismatch:

1. Compliance Issues:

  • Notice from Tax Authorities: When inconsistencies or discrepancies surface between the data presented in GSTR 3B, GSTR 9, and GSTR 9C, it often serves as a red flag for tax authorities. In response, they may issue a formal notice to your business. This notice can trigger a deeper investigation, requiring your company to provide clarifications or additional documentation to support the reported data. Failure to comply with such requests can intensify the situation.
  • Demand for Additional Tax Payment: A misalignment in your GST returns can result in the tax authorities demanding supplementary tax payments. Alongside these additional levies, your business may also be subject to interest charges and penalties. The severity of these consequences depends on the nature and extent of the discrepancies identified.
  • Reconciliation Requirements: To rectify discrepancies and bring your tax records to the GST regulations, tax authorities may instruct you to undertake a reconciliation process. This entails reconciling the variances between your reported figures in GSTR 3B, GSTR 9, and GSTR 9C and the actual financial data recorded by your business. Addressing these disparities often demands meticulous attention to detail.

2. Penalties and Interest:

  • Late Fees: Please submit GSTR 3B, GSTR 9, or GSTR 9C within the stipulated timelines and incur late filing fees. These charges can escalate with each day of delay, putting unnecessary financial strain on your organization.
  • Incorrect Tax Payment: You may be penalized if your GST returns contain errors underreporting your tax liability or overstatement of input tax credits. The monetary value of these penalties typically corresponds to a percentage of the misrepresented tax amount.
  • Interest on Late Payment: Discrepancies that lead to delayed tax payments can lead to the imposition of interest charges. These charges will accumulate until the outstanding tax liability is fully settled.

3. Legal Consequences:

  • Legal Proceedings: Persistent or significant discrepancies and non-compliance issues can escalate into legal proceedings initiated by the tax authorities. These proceedings may encompass thorough tax audits and investigations, potentially unearthing further irregularities. In severe cases, legal actions can result in substantial fines and even prosecution.
  • Loss of Input Tax Credit: Please rectify discrepancies in GSTR 3B, GSTR 9, or GSTR 9C, which may lead to the loss of input tax credits initially claimed based on erroneous data. This can impact your business’s bottom line and financial stability.
  • Blacklisting: Non-compliance or recurrent mismatches can lead to the blacklisting of your GSTIN (Goods and Services Tax Identification Number). This designation can seriously impede your ability to conduct business, as it may deter potential customers, suppliers, and financial institutions from engaging with your company.

4. Reputational Damage:

The fallout from non-compliance and legal entanglements related to GST can tarnish your business’s reputation. This damage extends beyond the financial realm and can adversely affect your relationships with key stakeholders, including suppliers, customers, and financial institutions. Rebuilding trust and credibility can be a protracted and challenging process.

5. Financial Impact:

The combined burden of penalties, interest charges, and additional tax payments from discrepancies can severely strain your business. Meeting these financial obligations may necessitate reallocating resources, affecting liquidity and overall financial health.

Conclusion:

The discrepancies between GSTR-3B, GSTR-9, and GSTR-9C can be quite complex for businesses. Simply put, businesses must keep accurate records, regularly check and correct differences, and follow GST rules properly. Finding and fixing these discrepancies on time is important to avoid legal and financial problems. Hence, businesses must pay close attention to these issues in their GST reporting and compliance procedures.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *